Gold IRA Scams

Since inflation is increasing, many are looking into gold and other precious metals as a way to diversify their investment portfolio and hedge against growing economic uncertainty.

Unfortunately, some unscrupulous dealers engage in fraudulent practices and use Gold IRAs to defraud unsuspecting investors. Therefore, you must be aware of these risks and equip yourself with extensive knowledge to identify them before it’s too late.

This comprehensive guide has been designed to help you understand how gold IRA scams work and give you some tips on how to avoid them to protect your nest egg. Read on! While we are on the topic, there is a lot of talk on what people are referring to as the American Hartford Gold scam. I can tell you that this is in fact NOT a scam!

Understanding Individual Retirement Accounts (IRA)

Understanding Individual Retirement Accounts

The basic concepts of individual retirement accounts revolve around individuals who can save long-term while enjoying certain tax benefits.

The Basics Of Traditional And Roth IRAs

There are several types of IRAs, and each offers different advantages to those who want to save for retirement. Let’s take a look at the differences between traditional and Roth IRAs while keeping in mind that these two types are the most common.

  • Traditional IRA: It’s a type of individual retirement account where contributions can be fully or partially tax deductible. Earnings and gains aren’t taxed until holders take a distribution.
  • Roth IRA: It’s a type of personal savings plan where contributions aren’t deductible. However, holders who meet certain requirements can take tax-free distributions.

Self-Directed IRA: An Overview

A self-directed individual retirement account or SDIRA allows people to hold non-traditional assets, such as gold and other precious metals.

Holders can directly manage these savings plans. That’s why they’re called “self-directed.”
Our detailed guide about self-directed IRAs offers a great insight where you can find out what the best self-directed IRAs are.

IRA Tax Implications And Penalties

The rules around IRAs can be confusing, but it’s important to understand and follow them. Otherwise, you could be penalized. Let’s look at the tax repercussions of IRA withdrawals depending on the account type.

Traditional IRAs

  • There’s a 10% penalty for people who make early withdrawals from their IRAs, specifically when they’re younger than 59 ½.
  • When claiming a deduction for a traditional IRA contribution, the money withdrawn is taxable. If contributions were nondeductible, part of the withdrawals would be tax-free.
  • In 2024, the maximum contribution limit is $7,000 or $8,000 for those who are 50 or older.
  • Traditional IRA investments grow tax-deferred, but withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income if made during retirement.
  • Holders should start taking money from the account at age 72.

Roth IRAs

  • Holders should take withdrawals after age 59½ and after a five-year holding period. Otherwise, they’re subject to 10% penalties.
  • The maximum annual Roth IRA contribution is $7,000, or $8,000 if you’re 50 or older, in 2024.
  • Roth IRA contributions, not earnings, can be withdrawn at any time and for any reason and will always be tax-free.

What Is A Gold IRA?

What is a Gold IRA?

The fundamentals of gold IRA lie in a self-directed individual retirement account. It allows investors to hold silver, palladium, platinum, and other valuable precious metals, such as gold, of course.

The Basics Of A Gold IRA

In a gold IRA, you can hold physical gold and other precious metals-related securities. These are some examples:

  • Gold coins, bars, and rounds
  • Silver coins, bars, and rounds
  • Platinum or palladium coins, bars, and rounds
  • Other physical forms of precious metals approved by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS)

Gold IRA Vs. Traditional IRA: A Comparison

Although both work similarly, there’s an important difference between gold IRAs and traditional accounts. The most important is that gold IRA holders can add precious metals to their investment portfolios.

In addition, gold IRA fees are typically higher than traditional IRAs because there will be costs for asset storage.

The Pros And Cons Of Gold IRA Investments

Let’s discuss the advantages and disadvantages of gold IRA investments may offer  to individuals who plan to save for retirement.


  • Tax advantages, such as tax-free withdrawals and tax-deferred investment growth
  • No high correlation with traditional assets, increasing diversification
  • Protection against economic uncertainty


  • Higher fees compared to traditional IRAs
  • No underlying cash flows or dividends
  • No authorization to hold stocks and other traditional investments

Gold IRA Regulations And Compliance

Gold IRAs also come with several rules, limitations, and penalties, including the following:

  • Gold IRA holders cannot store physical gold at home, as this would be considered a distribution under IRS rules.
  • To be eligible as gold IRA investments, precious metals must meet these purity standards: 99.5% purity for gold, 99.9% for silver, and 99.95% for platinum and palladium.
  • As a gold IRA holder, you cannot invest in non-compliant metals. Otherwise, you may face tax penalties.
  • Gold IRAs require a qualified and authorized custodian to hold assets.
  • Precious metals IRAs follow the same contribution limits as traditional IRAs, which are set at $7,000 or $8,000 (for people aged 50 or older) in 2024.
  • These accounts require minimum distributions as soon as holders turn 72.
  • Early withdrawals, before age 59½, may be subject to a 10% penalty and a 50% excise tax.
  • Gold IRA products cannot be used for personal benefits, and holders cannot sell personal assets to these accounts.
  • Indirect rollovers must be completed within 60 days. Otherwise, holders may face penalties, including an income tax on the distributed amount.

The Anatomy Of Gold IRA Scams

Anatomy of Gold IRA Scams

Unscrupulous dealers know that the government rules on individual retirement accounts are intricate and take advantage of this high level of complexity to run gold IRA scams.

Common Types Of Gold IRA Scams

These are the most common types of gold IRA scams:

High-Pressure Sales Tactics

Although this also occurs outside the gold industry, the number of cases of inappropriate high-pressure sale practices regarding gold IRAs has increased recently.

Delivery Of Different Products

Unfortunately, many scammers promise buyers that they’ll sell a specific product but deliver something else.

Inflated Prices

Some dishonest gold IRA companies have been found inflating prices. A firm faced legal action after increasing the profit margin on its products by 130%. Customers were only informed of a 1-5% markup.

Home Storage

No matter what a gold dealer tells you, no one can store their precious metals at home. All of the assets you have in your IRA must be managed by a custodian and stored by an approved depository. Any violation of this rule can result in penalties.

Sale Of Collectible Coins

Although there’s usually no criminal intent behind this, some precious metals dealers promote the sale of gold collectibles or rare coins even though most of these assets cannot be held in an IRA.

Outright Theft

Unfortunately, many gold IRA scams are just outright theft, which means a gold dealer takes a client’s money and just disappears.

Examples Of Gold IRA Scams

Here are some examples of gold IRA scams that have occurred in the past:

  • The Securities and Exchange Commission took legal action against three executives of a gold IRA company who were pressuring investors to sell other assets and buy gold.
  • The owner of Regal Assets disappeared with $10 million of the money invested by clients who believed his business was legitimate.
  • Some taxpayers created LLCs and tried to find loopholes to keep their precious metals at home but were penalized by the IRS.
  • A Texas man took orders for metal products but didn’t deliver his promises and sent fake metals to buyers.

How Gold IRA Scams Work

Gold IRA scams can work in several ways but often occur when dishonest gold dealers pressure people to make decisions in their favor, promise products and don’t deliver them, inflate prices, or violate IRS rules.

Impact Of Scams On Investors And Market

Besides impacting victims, who can lose their money and experience stress and anxiety, scams hit the gold industry and the market. These dishonest practices cause fear among potential investors. Consequently, this can impact market sentiment, which drives demand and supply and influences other key factors.

Red Flags To Watch Out For In Gold IRA Companies

Gold IRAs are legitimate and can help people save for their retirements. Although there are scams and risks, that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t put your money into these investments.

Instead, watch out for these red flags to identify dishonest gold IRA companies and potential scams:

Suspicious Sales Tactics

Is the dealer insisting that you sell your assets in your retirement accounts to buy gold or make an immediate purchase without allowing you to evaluate your decision? These are examples of the high-pressure sales tactics scammers often use.

Inconsistencies In Contracts And Documentation

Did you find inconsistencies in the contract? Does the company’s documentation look fake? If documents aren’t clear, or the information is different from what the salesperson told you, that could be a scam.

Unusual Investment Offers

Do you think the investment offer the gold dealer is making is too good to be true? Trust your gut! This may be a sign that it’s a scam.

Excessive And Hidden Fees

Reputable gold IRA companies should provide clear and transparent information about the costs of their products and services. Plus, rates should be reasonable.

If the dealer refuses to provide these details, there may be hidden fees, which means their prices aren’t as low as they seem.

Protecting Yourself From Gold IRA Scams

Are you still afraid of losing your savings to a scam? If you want to open a precious metals IRA and put your money into gold investments, you can also follow these tips to detect and avoid such dishonest practices.

Choosing A Reputable Dealer

Make sure you’re choosing a trustworthy gold company, custodian, and depository. To find out if they have a good reputation, look for online reviews and confirm their address using the street view function on Google Maps.

Verifying Licensure And Regulatory Compliance

Although these rules may vary from state to state, most businesses are required to register with their licensing division. To find this information and confirm how long a company has been operating in this industry, you can take a look at government databases, which are available online.

Ensuring Proper Storage And Insurance

Check if your custodian is really purchasing gold in your name and storing it in a trusted and approved depository by requesting purchase certification and other important documentation.

Also, ask for information about how your assets are insured. Reliable dealers will always protect your precious metal products.

Staying Informed And Vigilant

To avoid scams, never let your guard down. While it’s easy to spot many scams, some dishonest dealers have been fooling investors for years because their businesses look legitimate.

Stay informed about all the requirements companies must meet, common types of scams, and everything that’s happening in the industry. Vigilant and knowledgeable investors can manage risks better.

Understanding Market Volatility And Risk

Although gold investments are often used to protect portfolios against inflation, they can also be risky. Don’t fall for false promises. No one can guarantee you’ll get the results you expect or make a lot of money. If this happens, you’re probably facing a gold IRA scam.

Steps To Take If You Suspect A Gold IRA Scam

What should you do if you identify a gold IRA scam? If you believe that a company or dealer is trying to deceive you, offering illegal or fake bullion coins, or taking money from clients dishonestly, you can do the following:

Reporting The Scam

To report fraudulent gold IRA companies, you should submit a tip to the following entities:

  • Securities and Exchange Commission
  • Commodity Futures Trading Commission
  • Federal Trade Commission

In case of fraud, you can also file a report with your local police department.

Seeking Legal Assistance

Did you fall prey to a gold IRA scam? Contact a lawyer! Attorneys with experience in these cases can help you determine the best course of action and design a legal strategy to recover your funds.

Recovering Lost Funds

Consider whether there’s an opportunity to recover lost funds in addition to reporting the case and consulting with an attorney. In cases involving rollover scams, for example, victims could reverse transactions to get their money back to the original account.

Lessons Learned: Improving Investment Strategies

Have you been a victim of a gold IRA scam? Although it may be difficult to recover from this experience, be positive and try to learn from it to improve your future strategies and investment decisions.

Gold IRA Investment Best Practices

Gold IRA Investment

Are you considering putting your retirement savings into gold bullion coins or other precious metals? A gold IRA could be a good option! However, if you plan to invest in this type of account, you should understand how to use them.

The following best practices can help you make the most out of your precious metals IRA while ensuring you’re complying with IRS requirements.

Diversifying Your Portfolio

Portfolio diversification is a common investment technique that you can implement to mitigate the risks of significant financial losses.

This doesn’t mean you’ll always achieve the expected results, but spreading your investments around can help your portfolio withstand negative events that often affect only one asset.

Sticking To IRS-Approved Assets

It’s essential to understand that IRS rules state that precious metals IRA holders cannot purchase gold as a collectible but as a commodity. Rare coins don’t belong to these accounts! Therefore, you should always make sure you’re purchasing authentic and approved assets.

Monitoring Your Investments

Although it’s more stable than most popular paper assets, gold can also be impacted by global economic and political events. Geopolitical tensions, trade disputes, economic policies, and many other things can affect the value of your assets. That’s why you should always monitor them.

Understanding Liquidity And Exit Strategies

To use profits from their assets, investors should know exit strategies, such as liquidation and distribution options. Since precious metals have low liquidity compared to other products, learning about this topic is crucial.

Reputable Gold IRA Companies

How do you feel after reading this post? Do you think you’re ready to spot gold scams? If you still have doubts, you can consider choosing one of the three most respected gold IRA companies, which are:

Augusta Precious Metals

As the most popular and trusted gold IRA company in the US, Augusta Precious Metals has earned excellent ratings from the Better Business Bureau (BBB). This firm has been operating in this industry for over a decade and has zero complaints so far!

Moreover, Augusta Precious Metals offers investment educational materials and is 100% transparent about its costs.


Known for its top-class customer service, Goldco is another reliable gold IRA company you can find in the US. It has been in business for over 10 years without accumulating customer complaints. The firm’s knowledgeable and friendly representatives will be always willing to help you through your investment process!

American Hartford Gold

This is another leading precious metals dealer in the US. American Hartford Gold has earned an A+ from the Better Business Bureau, demonstrating that customers are satisfied with its services.

Evaluating Gold IRA Companies

Are you wondering how you can find a reputable gold IRA company? These are the aspects you should look at before making a decision:

  • Proven track record: If the company has a high turnover and has been operating in the industry for years, that’s a good sign.
  • Positive reviews: Reputable gold IRA companies always go the extra mile to ensure their clients are satisfied and happy with their services. Check reviews and feedback from other people and choose those firms with a good reputation. Avoid those with unresolved complaints.
  • Transparent pricing information: Firms that aren’t clear about their prices could be charging hidden fees, meaning you’d have to pay more than their services or products are actually worth. Avoid these companies and choose the ones that disclose rates upfront.
  • Responsive and comprehensive customer service: You’re entrusting your dealer with your life savings. Therefore, it’s important to make sure they’re willing to answer your questions. Make some calls and send some emails to test response times.
  • Approved storage options: Make sure the company offers legal storage alternatives since precious metals must be stored in a depository or financial institution approved by the IRS. Home storage is illegal!
  • Consumer protections: Choose companies that are members of organizations that require firms to adhere to strict consumer protection standards in order to be eligible for their memberships. Such firms are often reliable!

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Gold IRAs Legit?

Yes, they are! While it’s true that no type of investment comes with a guarantee, precious metals have historically been used as a hedge against inflation and are considered stable assets. Additionally, gold IRAs offer tax advantages and are subject to IRS regulations.

What Is The Downside Of A Gold IRA?

Gold IRAs may have some disadvantages, such as the need for specific and expensive storage. Plus, potential growth is limited, and holders don’t earn interest or dividends.

How Do I Get Out Of A Gold IRA?

If you want to withdraw your funds from a gold IRA without penalties, you must wait until you turn 59 ½. Otherwise, such withdrawals will be considered non-qualified distributions, which are subject to taxes and penalties of 10%.

How Do Gold Scams Work?

There are different types of gold scams, and each one works differently. However, most focus on pressuring people to sell or buy gold to favor dealers, inflating prices, failing to deliver products to buyers, and violating rules set by the IRS.

What Are The Tax Implications Of Investing In A Gold IRA?

Tax implications vary depending on the type of gold IRA. If it’s traditional, you don’t pay taxes on contributions but on withdrawals.

However, things are different if you have a Roth gold IRA. In that case, contributions aren’t tax-deductible, but you don’t have to pay taxes on withdrawals.

How Can I Check The Legitimacy Of A Gold IRA Company?

In order to check the legitimacy of a gold IRA company to avoid scams, you should conduct exhaustive research on that firm, verify its contact information and physical address, be wary of dealers who request upfront payment, and make sure the contract is clear.


Although the gold industry can offer many benefits to investors, some dishonest dealers are engaging in illegal practices to deceive precious metals buyers.

However, this doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t invest in a gold IRA. While there are risks, you can avoid scams by being cautious and following the tips we shared above!

Similar Posts