From the Media Lounge

 border=

Research in Focus
« Our Fiscal Security releases plan to create jobs, make critical public investments and reduce federal deficit | Main | Demos Responds: Bipartisan Policy Center Plan Fails To Address Declining Middle Class »

A Perverse Austerity Plan

By Robert Kuttner

THE UNEMPLOYMENT rate remains stuck at close to 10 percent. Meanwhile, despite low interest rates, banks are reluctant to lend and businesses are hesitant to invest. Mortgage foreclosures keep rising and real estate values falling. And with the federal stimulus petering out, state budgets anticipate more service cuts and layoffs.

Yet to read the newspapers and watch TV news and talk shows, you would think the top menace facing the country is the projected federal budget deficit in 2020.

The two chairs of President Obama’s bipartisan fiscal commission, Democrat Erskine Bowles and Republican Alan Simpson, are promoting an austerity package that would begin cutting public outlay in less than a year. The panel is due to report December 1.

Just for good measure, a private deficit commission chaired by former GOP Senator Pete Domenici and Democratic deficit hawk Alice Rivlin is going the official panel one better, proposing $5.9 trillion in tax hikes and spending cuts over eight years, compared to the $3.8 trillion proposed by the president’s panel.

Economic masochism has become the national fad, when the real issue is restoring economic growth. According to Bowles, if we don’t act soon to rein in the deficit, the economy is on “a path of absolute disaster.’’ Excuse me, but the disaster is here and has nothing to do with projected future deficits.

There are three huge flaws in the austerity program.

First, in a deep and prolonged slump, the economy needs more public outlay, not less, to make up for a paralyzed private economy. With depressed consumer spending, reduced business investment, weak banks, and declining property values each dragging the other down, standard economics dictates that only government demand can step into the breach.

During the Great Depression, the economy got stuck in a similar downdraft. Though weak growth returned by 1934, unemployment was still stuck above 12 percent on the eve of World War II. It was the massive wartime deficits (peaking at 28 percent of GDP compared to less than 9 percent today) that finally produced strong recovery.

Postwar leaders, unlike today’s deficit hawks, were wise enough not to panic about the large war debt (twice today’s size relative to the economy) but continued such public investments as the GI bill, low-interest home loans, and the interstate highway system. Rather than suffering an austerity scheme that would have made debt loom larger, the postwar boom enabled the economy to grow its way out of debt.

The second flaw is the timing and composition of the proposed deficit reduction plan. Just as after World War II, we need a long-term path to a lower debt. But hikes in taxes and cuts in spending should begin only when the economy is back at full employment, not next year. And the proposed mix of tax increases and spending cuts in the Bowles-Simpson plan is grotesque.

Everything is supposed to be on the table, but repealing the Bush tax cuts for the wealthy is not part of the proposed package. Nor are other notable increases in taxation of the best-off. Two thirds of the deficit-reduction would come from cuts in spending, and the proposed revenue increases would mostly hit the middle class.

A third flaw is the inclusion of Social Security cuts. Social Security has nothing to do with the current deficit, and is in surplus for the next 27 years. If we want to balance the projected long-term Social Security accounts after 2037, the best way is to get more people working and wages growing again, since Social Security is financed by taxes on payrolls.

The deficit hawks have not plausibly explained the connection between belt-tightening and recovery. Supposedly, we need to show our resolve to lower the debt years down the road, in order to give businesses confidence. But let’s get real: business is failing to invest because of lack of demand, not because of worries about deficits in 2020.

Commentators are clucking that the commission may deadlock because its Republicans won’t raise taxes and its Democrats won’t cut spending. We should only be so lucky. If the commission fails, we can get back to the real economic business of promoting a robust recovery.

Robert Kuttner is co-editor of The American Prospect and a senior fellow at Demos. His latest book is “A Presidency in Peril.’’ 

This article originally appeared in The Boston Globe

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

References (1)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.

Reader Comments (20)

What I would like to see is an explanation of why conservatives are such supposed defecit hawks. Is this just a short term rhetorical trick to gain advantage in the midterm elections, or are the super wealthy actually afraid these defecits will threaten their ecenomic advantages?

November 29, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterAlex S. Vitale

In winter, uggs outlet, without doubt, ugg bailey button triplet is one of the most well-known shoes. The cold season of 2011 will bring this item with versions to suit all tastes uggs for cheap.
The cheap ugg boots are going to become IN this season.
Do you like this form of boots?
Which do you prefer? The rough hard boots which you could kick some zombie butt in. Or the beautiful delicateness of ugg sheepskin cuff that bring you a
little feminine touch. I want to hear everyone's opinion. I like currently being ready to defend myself that's why i love my fight boots i got from
an wonderful ugg boots sale store.
Ankle boots are at present my favorite varieties of footwear.
As it is possible to see in ugg boots sale uk, celebrities like: Erin Wasson, Kate Moss, Nicole Richie, and Jessica Alba have been rocking this type,
uggs on sale are going to be quite "in-stlye" this fall and also winter.
So do you like ankle boots for ugg boots clearance?
Are they a hit or miss for you?
I produced this look on ugg boots outlet and attempted to create two appears with just one particular dress by styling it in distinct methods.
louis vuitton outlet is an incredibly cute but additionally sophisticated louis vuitton dress simultaneously and also the coral color is simply remarkable!
The first look is a single you may put on to function when you like a more fashionable louis vuitton neverfull for working. I utilized the dress as a base then added a
brown leather biker the north face jacket, a washed off brown jegging and some brown ankle boots with straps in the north face outlet.

October 19, 2011 | Unregistered Commenteruggs outlet

Moncler Jackets are some of the most unique men’s outerwear on the market today. When you wear a Moncler, you aren’t wearing a jacket – you are wearing a piece of art.
For Moncler mens jackets, men's clothing choices will give you a good platform. Taste is a handsome gentleman shows a man, from design to production of Moncler is very strict.
Moncler Jackets, Moncler womens jackets, Moncler Coats, Moncler Vest, Moncler Kids are featured products of Moncler.
Shop for cheap Moncler Jackets from the best Moncler outlet.

October 26, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMoncler Coats

Welcome to our sites ,we can offer you the best quality and the best price's jerseys.
nfl jerseys
nfl jackets
youth nfl jerseys

November 3, 2011 | Unregistered Commenteryouth nfl jerseys

Mark van Bommel says the upcoming match between the Netherlands and Germany is not a

friendly,wholesale nfl jerseys
nfl jerseys wholesale
insisting that Tuesday night’s match in Hamburg will be an emotiona

November 13, 2011 | Unregistered Commentercheap nfl jerseys

New Line are north face store of Time Warner Inc.; MGM is owned by a group of former creditors including Highland Capital, Anchorage Advisors and Carl Icahn; Lionsgate is owned by Lions Gate Entertainment Corp.; cheap north face is owned by Rainbow Media Holdings, a subsidiary of Cablevision Systems Corp.; Rogue is owned by Relativity Media LLC.

November 14, 2011 | Unregistered Commenternorth face store

In winter, <h1>uggs outlet<h1>, without doubt, <h1>ugg bailey button triplet<h1> is one of the most well-known shoes. The cold season of 2011 will bring this item with versions to suit all tastes <h1>uggs for cheap<h1>.
The <h1>cheap ugg boots<h1> are going to become IN this season.
Do you like this form of boots?
Which do you prefer? The rough hard boots which you could kick some zombie butt in. Or the beautiful delicateness of <h1>ugg sheepskin cuff<h1> that bring you a
little feminine touch. I want to hear everyone's opinion. I like currently being ready to defend myself that's why i love my fight boots i got from
an wonderful <h1>ugg boots sale<h1> store.
Ankle boots are at present my favorite varieties of footwear.
As it is possible to see in <h1>ugg boots sale uk<h1>, celebrities like: Erin Wasson, Kate Moss, Nicole Richie, and Jessica Alba have been rocking this type,
<h1>uggs on sale<h1> are going to be quite "in-stlye" this fall and also winter.
So do you like ankle boots for <h1>ugg boots clearance<h1>?
Are they a hit or miss for you?
I produced this look on <h1>ugg boots outlet<h1> and attempted to create two appears with just one particular dress by styling it in distinct methods.
<h1>louis vuitton outlet<h1> is an incredibly cute but additionally sophisticated <h1>louis vuitton<h1> dress simultaneously and also the coral color is simply remarkable!
The first look is a single you may put on to function when you like a more fashionable <h1>louis vuitton neverfull<h1> for working. I utilized the dress as a base then added a
brown leather biker <h1>the north face<h1> jacket, a washed off brown jegging and some brown ankle boots with straps in <h1>the north face outlet<h1>.

November 16, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterugg boots sale

When 1st receiving the boots from ugg boots outlet, you should very first check to see that the boots are in brand new condition. One can by no means be too picky when purchasing UGG boots. As soon as you see that the boots are in brand new condition ugg bailey button, you'll be able to begin the caring procedure for your ugg bailey button.Inspect the component in the sole where it meets the heel. On the real Ugg Australia boots, they have a flush join ugg boots sale, meaning the sole style gradually tapers off into a flat heel. On their fake ugg bailey button sale counterparts, they typically meet at a ridge along with a solid line clearly shows exactly where sole along with the heel meet.Inspect the part in the sole where it meets the heel. On the real ugg bailey button triplet, they've a flush join, which means the sole design gradually tapers off into a flat heel. On their fake counterparts, they usually meet at a ridge plus a solid line clearly shows ugg outlet store sole along with the heel meet.Ugg Australia Argyle boots might be worn slouched or full up. They go best with tights, jeans, a comfy sweater and just about any casual outfit. These will surely be the hottest selling Ugg boots this fall and winter and surely grow to be harder and harder to locate as the cold season comes in ugg classic tall sale.The origins of Uggs are really disputed with both Australia and New Zealand claiming to ugg bailey button triplet sale the originators with the Ugg boot. The term ugg classic short sparkles are in fact a generic term in those countries despite the fact that in the rest in the world the copyright in the term is held by an American business ugg boots clearance.UGG boots appear and really feel wonderful due to the fact in the sheepskin and wool utilised to make every single pair ugg classic short sparkles. Both wool and Sheepskin are very delicate, so your UGGs ought to never be placed in a washing machine or dryer.

December 6, 2011 | Unregistered Commentercoach purse outlet

These bags add convenience and <h1>Coach Outlet</h1> for girls to steer. Each fashionable<h1>Coach Outlet Online</h1> are created and developed with plenty of <h1>Coach Outlet Online</h1> to ensure it does not leave <h1>Coach Factory Outlet</h1> behind or beyond. These<h1>Coach Factory Outlet</h1> are the women of <h1>Coach Outlet Store Online</h1>, wherever <h1>Coach Factory</h1> goes, whether a <h1>Coach Factory</h1> or <h1>Coach Factory Outlet Online</h1> an open-air<h1>Coach Factory Online</h1>ogether. So, these classic <h1>Coach Factory Online</h1> are created with <h1>Coach Outlet Online Store</h1>of upscale <h1>Louis Vuitton Bags</h1>. Before <h1>Burberry Scarf</h1>, please guarantee coach outlet online that the stand is consolidated fully, and provides the normal product in the pocket friendly discount.

December 6, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterCoach Online

along with typically the newest of going north face jackets clearance tattooed. It can be vastly agreed on women north face sale with contemporary society as opposed to just Canada goose outlet before moncler jackets a particular skin icon for your needs. Canada Goose Sale For those who are still clueless of Columbia Jackets the items structure to use your skin, the north face jackets you’ll be able to resort. 25w

December 6, 2011 | Unregistered Commenternorth face clearance

There are womens motorcycle jackets that come with fringe, which arcteryx may think is there just for looks. from lowland variant to mountaineering variant. The classic motorcycle jacket has a wide collar that snaps down, arcteryx jackets cuffs, and a belt.

December 13, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterfhsr

Very good! Also can go here to have a look.
rolex air king

December 14, 2011 | Unregistered Commentercary

Love sports , love jerseys ,and you will become more and more beautiful!
nfl jersey wholesale
cheap nfl jerseys
cheap nhl jersey
Custom Jerseys
nfl jerseys
mlb baseball jerseys
This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It’s the old what goes around comes around routine.

December 16, 2011 | Unregistered Commenternfl jersey wholesale

dsas231d3a2s1f3as
Paul appeals <h1>Coach Purses Outlet</h1> to people <h1>Coach Factory Outlet</h1> whose knowledge <h1>Coach Factory Outlet</h1> of major <h1>Coach Factory Outlet Online</h1> issues is <h1>Coach Factory Outlet Online</h1> superficial (and) <h1>Coach Outlet Online</h1> he sees <h1>Coach Factory Outlet</h1> conspiracies where <h1>Coach Purses</h1> there are none <h1>Coach Factory Outlet</h1>," said Greg <h1>Coach Factory Store</h1> Valliere, chief <h1>Coach Outlet Store Online</h1> political strategist <h1>Coach Outlet Online Store</h1> at Potomac <h1>Coach Outlet Online</h1> Research Group <h1>Coach Outlet</h1>, an analysis firm. <h1>Coach Outlet</h1> "If he does <h1>Cheap Coach Bags</h1> well in Iowa <h1>Coach Factory Outlet Online</h1>, which is <h1>Coach Outlet Online</h1> likely, it <h1>Coach Outlet Store Online</h1> will be <h1>Coach Bags</h1>
an enormous embarrassment to the Republicans."However, Paul's calls for a dramatically limited government and a hands-off foreign policy are resonating among voters who have grown deeply alienated from Washington after a decade of war and nearly five years of economic malaise

December 27, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterCoach Factory Outlet

coach outlet can provide the coach exactly the same is expected in a retail store. It can help you find bags of various colors, shapes and designs, which prove once again that the coach is actually a selection for the housekeeper.coach outlet store online with fashion style and top quality succeed. In any occasions they are very suitable and appropriate for its precise and rich design.
louis vuitton uk are diversified in various kinds, handbags, backpacks, portable bags, purses, wallets and pouches. All kinds are popular among the whole word people.in fact, louis vuitton is one of the most famous fashion design master.he opened the fist suitcase shop called after his name.
It's wonderful to find out it does not slip in your signature at the bottom of the case and the appearance of brass accents from coach outlet online, Because women who can look stylish this summer.Here you can find the latest products in different kinds of coach outlet store online making best materials.They are leisure practical products in the new generations.
As we show below, louis vuitton outlet have a number of Louis Vuitton Earrings, louis vuitton replica handbags, in different styles for your selection.If you're an gal who actually will become a great deal of revenue each and every month, you'll possess the capability to pay the high expense of any louis vuitton bags.
Welcome to buy Discount Louis Vuitton Bags and Authentic Louis Vuitton in our louis vuitton sale.Absolutely guaranteed quality and making every details greatest in products our company principle.Welcome to visit our louis vuitton outlet, whatever you like, our shop can supply to you.Launched in honor of the 2004 Euro Cup in Portugal, the Attaquant gets its original shape from the soccer ball.
Modern designs and faddish shapes make Coach products enjoy high reputations around the world. coach factory outlet a shopping place just for you.Coach handbags from the coach factory online are popular now because of the colorful fabric. It is fashionable and beautiful. You can see the opening of the bag like wave, which is its special design.
coach factory outlet has a big heart and a healthy appetite, and a wicked swing with a chainsaw. After a knee injury ended his career as a defensive lineman in college, Coach salvaged his Physical Education degree(barely)and landed a job teaching health at the local high school in his hometown of Savannah.coach factory outlet online is a fashion brand to ensure its quality. With designer coach shoulder bags, you will always attract people's attention. The bags will emphasize your personal style and taste.
This louis vuitton uk for sale belongs to the sounding just what are termed as Louis Vuitton vintage best sellers, many other products and services for the reason that range appearing companies.If you want to catch up to the latest vogue, having louis vuitton Handbags of the latest styles can absolutely satisfy you.Just visit LV outlet webpage and select the most suitable products for yourself.
Attention! coach outlet is offering new products at favorable prices for August. Brighter colors, finer looks and newer designs, all bring you a whole new summer.coach outlet store online has been voted by Hour Detroit magazine readers as the Best of Detroit in their 12th annual readers'poll.
Coach Handbags were made in 1941 in Manhattan, with high technology and good craftsmanship. coach outlet store is becoming more and more famous today.As a fashion and modern lady, you can never have too many bags but Coach, Coach is a great leather handbags brand. coach outlet store online have different look according to different designer concept.
Our Coach backpack from coach outlet online can make you elegant.The feel is luxurious, the look is stunning. The Coach backpack has enough space to carry many necessities such as umbrella, books and clothes.Here you can find the latest products in different kinds of coach outlet store online making best materials.They are leisure practical products in the new generations.
The Coach bag is from the latest release of Coach Bags. Its crisp, scribble material, leather handle, perfectly complements the relaxed shape of this stylish pouch. All the items of coach outlet online Store fit all of your essentials and more.You know, Coach items are so perfect and fascinating. Now I grow up, and find coach outlet on the Internet offering affordable products with reliable quality.
The coach bags are utilized for formal event in company area that will display your excellent taste.Not only does a briefcase make is easier to carry things.Coach is a leading American designer and maker of luxury lifestyle handbags and accessories.There is no doubt that here coach outlet store is the exact place you should visit.
hermes birkin shall ship the items via DHL or EMS in 12-48 hours once your payment is cleared, and your parcels usually arrive in the next 3-7 business days. If for any dissatisfied reasons, you can request for an exchange or refund within 14 days upon receipt of the order in a resalable condition.The hermes bags are amazing and you will rest assured by proudly owning a bed that you will find yourself envied by simply your colleagues.
For the past few years, armani watches has been on such a great roll with resort collections, and for good reason. The brand's identity is built around the idea of luxury travel.One of my friend wants to buy a gift for her mother on the Mother's Day. She asks me, I suggest her to buy emporio armani watches, which has good quality and unique design.

December 28, 2011 | Unregistered Commentercoach outlet

Judging louis vuitton speedy from the purses that they carry could possibly be the way for males to inform the likely with the lady he is thinking about louis vuitton speedy 25. In fac,t this could be a really fascinating conversation opener as well louis vuitton speedy sale. The fact that women need to carry the essentials in the handbag factors out the preemptive strategy that women should guarantee that they're ready for louis vuitton shop online any style disaster. On the other hand, in case a woman is carrying a bag which can be not accommodating enough louis vuitton speedy 30, would that suggest that she is confident that she could take care of the predicament with out the essentials some way or a different.cheap louis vuitton really is just 1 of the adaptations which make Vuitton Pegase bag an ideal one for travel purposes. louis vuitton neverfull GM consist of its extended take care of, which tends to make it simple to pull close to airports and railway stations, plus the reality that it truly is produced in the rather sturdy monogram canvas. Monogram canvas, as well as staying an exceptionally gorgeous materials which doesn't effortlessly drop color with the passage of time, louis vuitton speedy 30 with shoulder strap is also a very robust material; excellent for any louis vuitton luggage bag which needs to withstand pretty somewhat of pressure over its lifetime speedy louis vuitton.Recognizing that, unless a single has grown up inside a household of purse collectors or had some sort of similar knowledge of being all around genuine louis vuitton neverfull of excellent, some education is in order. A number of people suggest going to louis vuitton shop online outlet shops and examining the goods discovered there. Such a strategy could be an benefit, since the sales staff may be prepared to reveal tiny flaws louis vuitton outlet online that landed specific objects in the outlet shop.When you may have encounter replica handbags which look, for your eye, to become louis vuitton purses outlet online identical towards the unique, they'll be constructed from inferior supplies and will not have virtually the good quality of workmanship for which genuine Louis Vuitton Wallets are renowned. Your replica handbag could disintegrate inside louis vuitton purse outlet a somewhat brief time, whilst an authentic Louis Vuitton, if cared for, will final a lifetime.

December 29, 2011 | Unregistered Commenteruggs outlet

One more great place that Louis vuitton Outlet louis vuitton replica louis vuitton bags louis vuitton sale Lv bags on sale I looked for lv louis vuitton store replica louis vuitton louis vuitton luggage was Ripoffreport.com and what louis vuitton replica bags fake louis vuitton replica louis vuitton luggage fake louis vuitton wallet I ran across was a worldwide answer for scams faux louis vuitton bags louis vuitton replica luggage louis vuitton replicas faux louis vuitton handbags .Thankfully, one of louis uitton louis vuitton imitation purses cheap louis vuitton bags those days I put Replica fake louis vuitton purses replica lv dog carrier replica louis vuitton bags andbags in the search results and christian louboutin replica replica christian louboutin fake christian louboutin christian louboutin eplicas discovered a louboutin replica herve leger replica dresses fake louboutin shoes christian louboutin daffodil good amount of websites that sell reproduction shoes and bags. I'd state that the herve leger dress replica herve leger replica knockoff louboutin louboutin replica shoes est way for me to replica louboutins replica loubotin louboutins knockoffs louboutin knockoffs etermine a great footwear louboutin daffodil christian louboutin replica uk christian louboutin Christian Louboutin Knockoffs was to see a number Christian Louboutin HeelsHerve Leger Dress of pictures Herve Leger Bandage Dress red bottom shoes where I could christian louboutin alti christian louboutin men replica view every detail replica christian louboutin sneakers that I had to seechristian louboutin replica boots christian louboutin highness .

January 5, 2012 | Unregistered Commentergeshen

Washington Redskins at the end of the game earlier today to 23-10 victory over the New York Giants,
cheap hockey jersey
mlb baseball jerseys
NFL premier jerseys
nfl jerseys
Custom Jerseys
which makes the Philadelphia Eagles retained playoff hopes. In the next game, the Hawks must beat the Dallas Cowboys on the road and at home to win the game with the Redskins, and Giants and Jets also lost at home against the Cowboys, the Hawks can get postseason race seat. Jets winning streak in the outstanding performance during the Mark - Sanchez 26 times the field completed 15 passes, only advancing 150 yards, 2 touchdowns, four captured and killed, 2 steals.

January 6, 2012 | Unregistered Commenternfl jerseys

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>